The First Nashville Seventh-day Adventist Church
A Historical Sketch
written by John Casillas - 1999; rev. 2/8/2000
table of contents
Let us fill this blessed house!
The sun rise warm upon your face
forward
In accepting the task of writing about the history of our beloved First Nashville Seventh-day Adventist Church I was impressed to seek information and counsel from many sources. As with any endeavor to reconstruct history, there are periods of time that remain unaccounted for. Accordingly, this small essay should be considered a work in progress. While trying to be as accurate as possible, there are undoubtedly some errors in the retelling of our history and as they are discovered, this account will be edited.
Many of the stories graciously provided by the senior of our flock are fearfully engaging; that is, the fear that one has when confronting the very face of God. I have come to believe that God's Holy Face shines as a clear beacon over this congregation through our rich history. We've so many incredulous stories which reveal the tremendous love of Jesus as He helped the early congregation to create this wonderful place of worship.
While reading some accounts I could not hold back the tears. How can I recount the tremendous "cloud of witnesses" that have gone before us to make this structure our Sabbath home? So dear to my heart will be the many unsung heroes that gave so much of themselves for this church. They reveal a fountain of blessings straight from the heart of our blessed Redeemer. Even though their names have faded from our collective memory, their self-sacrificing gifts should never be forgotten.
Friends, there is a unique and wondrous history interwoven in the stone, brick and mortar that make up this consecrated edifice. Imbued by the Holy Spirit people from near and far came to Nashville as the Advent message reached the ears of the South.
They came for different reasons: S.N. Haskel from New York City, Brother and Sister L. A. Hansen from Battle Creek Michigan, J.E. White, who moved his press from the river boat "Morning Star" to a barn on Grand Avenue, near Vanderbilt University, to start publishing the a precursor of our now globally distributed Advent Review which he called, "The Gospel Herald".
Each one came in response to a divine call. Each one sought to improve the Advent work. And perhaps not so surprising, each one had a unique agenda which was altered, bent and molded into the well being of the whole congregation. These talents, expressed in and through the sweet unifying agency of the Holy Spirit, formed the basis of the movement to build the very first Adventist congregation in the South. And this very congregation evolved into the First Nashville Seventh-day Adventist Church.
It is my sincere hope that those searching for a place of worship may find our church filled with the warm light which shines in the very face of Jesus Christ. I pray that as you continue your walk with our Blessed Savior you will find, as I have, that our church family earnestly desires to provide you with comfort, warmth, love and spiritual enrichment and edification. Amen.
converging roots
"In the New England area, a little over one hundred and fifty years ago, William Miller began preaching the soon return of Jesus. Out of this movement developed the Seventh-day Adventist Church." This is how one of our members, Mrs. Eunice Kathka, begins her narrative of our church. My first thought as I read her document was 'why is she starting back in 1844...at the very beginning of our Advent movement?'
I soon came to realize that in order to understand our church history one must go back to that wonderful time. Because it was during the mid to late 1800s that various groups advancing the cause of God in the South started to find, quite unintentionally, that Nashville provided the sure footing for expanded work into the area.
Thus in 1900 J.E. White moved his press from the famous river boat "Morning Star" to a barn on Grand Avenue in Nashville. His original intention was to anchor the work of publications in Vicksburg, Mississippi, however he simply couldn't make it "stick" there. His work flourished in Nashville and was later taken over by the General Conference, thus starting the Southern Publishing House, the publishers of today's Advent Review, which is distributed around the globe.
Likewise the Hansens thought to begin their ministry in Vicksburg. Here again circumstance diverted them to Nashville and in 1897 they set up treatment rooms in an abandoned store in town which started our medical work in the South, much earlier than the Madison Sanitarium which was considered at that time to be "out in the country."
Against the back drop of the missions of Edson White and the Hansens, Shirley C. Eldridge, who not only graced our church as a respected Elder but also earned the title of Mr. G.N.J.A for his years of dedication to Greater Nashville Junior Academy, (our private school), writes:
"One hundred fourteen years ago R.K. McCune, a young Nashville resident, received some literature from the Tract Society and accepted as truth what he read. When he sent an urgent appeal to Battle Creek for a minister to come and preach to the little company of people who were meeting together because of their common interest in this literature, Elbert B. Lane responded." In 1873 meetings "were held in the waiting room of the Edgefield Junction railroad station, and soon a church of thirteen members was organized - the first Adventist church in the South."
Was it a strange twist of fate that brought these parties to Nashville during the turn of the century? Ellen G. White, co-founder of the Seventh-day Adventist church, writes concerning this matter:
"As a people we should take a special interest in the work at Nashville. At the present time {1902} this city is of great importance in the Southern field. Our brethren selected Nashville as a center for the work in the South because the Lord in His wisdom directed them there. It is a favorable place in which to make a beginning." Testimonies, Vol. 7, p. 232.
Fragmented Efforts.
There are many accounts of Seventh-day "Adventurers", as they were sometimes called, who sought to build a ministry in the Southland. They came from all quarters and met with varying degrees of success.
D.T. Shireman of Iowa, literally cut out the rural town of Hildebran, NC, from the wilderness and planted a school, an orphanage and a church. Later the place would gain considerable acreage and Peidmont Sanitarium was built only to be destroyed by fire. As many of the buildings owned in the South in those days were uninsured, the loss was complete and as monies couldn't be raised to rebuild, the land was sold and debts paid.
Another effort occurred in 1903 when the Mississippi Lumber Company donated 160 acres of wild land to the church. The N.W. Pierces pitched their tent on the property and went to work, cultivating 16 acres in one year in which they set out 230 peach trees and 600 grapevines, plus fig trees and other small fruits. In very short time a school was built. A Mr. and Mrs. Parker Atwood joined the group to help the small institution.
In 1902 an intermediate school started in Hazel, Kentucky. Charles L. Stone and his wife applied their administrative skills to this place and through much hard work and prayer the school became established as the Hazel Industrial Intermediate School and provided many fine years of service to the church.
All of these efforts were sorely needed in the South and as more and more attention was directed southward, Adventists came to establish strong and vibrant educational and health ministries. Yet the work proceeded painfully slow in relation to the rest of the country. Even Florida was being worked before Adventists could gain a foothold in the Southland.
Impact of the Civil War.
One of the main reasons why the Advent message was slow in taking root in the South can be directly attributable to one of the saddest and most remarkable periods of this country's history - the Civil War. That war had left the South painfully crippled. How she had fallen!
Previous to the war, the South contained nearly half of the nation's wealth. She took great pride in her British ancestry and set in place the aristocratic pattern of Europe with large plantation owners commanding great respect. Her houses, lands, highways and byways were filled with fabulous luxury and splendor and one could easily understand how she became a self-contained land of her own. She would not bow down readily to an integrated Union.
The Civil War dramatically changed the Southland. From a powerful slave economy living in the cradle of wealth she fell, leaving an aftermath of indescribable horror. Both the North and the South had their share of devastation, the North losing 360,000 men and the South 258,000.
Against such a backdrop, how would the Southland react towards reform movements coming from the North? Would not the brows of suspicion and anger be raised? Humiliated and defeated, brooding from the effects of "Reconstruction", the people of the South seemed uninterested in so called "new truths", especially in the areas of religion and education.
Yet a foothold was gained through the fragmented approaches of concerned family members who were moved by the Holy Spirit to act. God's strength is best revealed through man's weakness. Denominational literature was sent here and there. Over time the seeds planted began to grow. And as minds were convicted there arose small groups or "companies" of folk who fell in love with the Advent message.
The Company at Edgefield Junction.
One such company began to meet a few miles north of Nashville at a place called "Edgefield Junction." Here, amidst canisters of paint and the smell of thinners, they met to share their deepening faith in Jesus Christ. As their conviction grew, more people joined and eventually Elbert B. Lane of Indiana began his ministry for the group in 1871.
Another account of this small band of believers reads that in the space of a few weeks, the group had to move to the train station's baggage room and then to an outside platform. Two to three hundred people started to come to hear the Advent message - the very first time Adventists held public meetings in the Southland.
Unfortunately, Pastor Lane could only stay a few weeks as he was called back to his own state to organize the Indiana Conference. But he didn't forget that little train station and in 1873, he came back and organized the small company into a church of 13 members.
Perhaps herein lies a timeless lesson for God's people. Can you imagine the concern of Elder Lane as he baptized the group? Can you hear the conversations of the church members as they eagerly sought God in prayer to console them? From such a large showing of interest, they were left with but 13 members. Were they really being lead by God? Fully convicted, they decided to press on.
Many of the brave souls answering the call to ministry weren't educated or even ordained. They were volunteers - lay people who were seeking to fulfill God's mission in their own lives. These people reached out and touched others and rather than sent forth from institutions, pursued their work earnestly through the unction of the Holy Spirit.
As I read the varying accounts of this time my mind couldn't help but imagine how our Lord operates for the good of His people. At a time of maximum need, He impressed workers to come to the area. Through the support of the church leadership, Nashville became a successful staging ground for the Advent work in the South.
With your imagination listen to the conversations that took place between Edson White, the Hansens and Elder Lane. Each one was diverted from their mission and landed at Nashville. Each were a part of that early congregation at Edgefield Junction. Each had hit bottom until setting up shop in Nashville.
Now, even though through no small effort, they simply couldn't believe how wondrously God had poured out His blessings upon them! Here, they knew instinctively that their work finally found a sure anchor. Here in Nashville their separate agendas united with the will of God and the work was moving forward!
I can envision them coming together in praise and thanksgiving to our dear God! Can't you? Three separate missions, three separate agendas, now intrinsically related - converging - to fulfill God's purpose in the Southland.
Moves to Accommodate Growth.
How tightly would they weave their purposes? In 1901 Edson White moved his printing business into a two story brick building on 10th or 12th and Jefferson Street and donated a large room on the second floor where the growing company of believers, lead by Elder Lane, held their Sabbath services. The Hansens, whose medical ministry was gaining prominence in Nashville were part of this early congregation.
As growth came to that little flock, they began to feel the need to be recognized as a regular denomination. In order to secure this it was important that they build or buy a church. And, as always in the cause of God, an unusual twist or turn of events found that the Baptist Church on 5th and Fatherland Street was being offered for sale for the asking price of $5,000.
Again, we can tune into the conversations of that early congregation. 'How are we to afford this large sum of money? Should we not be content with our current situation? How are we to afford the maintenance for such a large building?'
Chief among the opposition to buy the Baptist church was Edson White. His reasoning appeared well founded for faced with a similar situation in Oakland, California, a congregation decided to buy and created a debt which burdened them for years. With the publishing house firmly established in Oakland the workers would receive good pay and this in turn would provide the core financial support necessary to buy or build a new church, Mr. White reasoned.
The congregation was challenged enough by having to pay six dollars a month for renting its current place of worship. This didn't include the ongoing costs the publishing house had sustained for insurance, lighting and maintenance. How would they raise the $1,000 down payment to secure the Fatherland church? How would they be able to afford a $4000 mortgage and ongoing operational costs of $30 per month on top of that?
One can imagine that such lively debates were commonplace as the Advent church multiplied in the area. Perhaps these are the same arguments that are made as Adventist communities continue to grow at a remarkable rate throughout the world.
Today, each day, over 2000 souls join the Adventist church around the globe. More than 10 million souls have embraced and hold close to their heart the Advent message. In each community there are those who grasp in fervent prayer the financial issues which need to be addressed to sustain the growing body of believers.
Help from the General Conference.
I can imagine that this small group spent many moments of intense prayer in seeking its next steps. Finally, they decided to dispatch Elder S.N. Haskell to the 1905 General Conference session meeting in Washington, DC, to plead for assistance. While the small company firmly fixed their objective on the Fatherland Baptist Church there was substance to the reasoning put forth not to load the congregation with debt as Mr. White carefully pointed out.
During hard times its difficult to see the hand of our Master. But looking back it all becomes so crystal clear. Mrs. Ellen G. White pulled Elder S.N. Haskell aside and shared with him a vision which was later recorded in the Review and Herald on September 7, 1905:
"For a long time the Sabbath-keepers of Nashville have met for worship in a room in the publishing house. But some have felt that in order to give a correct impression regarding the exalted character of our faith, we ought in some way to provide for a church building. But considering the lack of means, it seemed impossible to secure a suitable house of worship. About the time that Elder Haskell and his wife united with Elder Butler in labor at Nashville, the Lord instructed me in the night season to bear to the brethren and sisters in the South the following message:
"'God would have the standard lifted higher and still higher. The church cannot abridge her task without denying her Master. Meeting-houses must be built in many places...The Lord has instructed me that in some places there are buildings suitable for our work, and that we can secure these buildings at reasonable cost.'"
Elder Haskell tell us that Mrs. White told him, "Have faith in God. You will carry $5000 from this meeting." Indeed, back in 1903 the General Conference Committee voted to raise $100,000 for the establishment of worldwide headquarters. The monies had been pouring in for two years and it appeared that there would be several extra thousands to disperse.
The church leadership decided to provide the first $15,000 in excess funds towards the Review and Herald Publishing Association for the development of a suitable printing plant. However these plans were put aside when Mrs. White wrote a letter in July:
"During the time I was in Washington, the Lord was working in my mind in the night season. Light was given me while I was there that the first five thousand dollars of the overflow of the one hundred thousand dollars sent in for the work in Washington, was due to the Southern field and that it ought to be appropriated to the present urgent needs of the work in Nashville."
Now bear in mind that this "Washington Fund", as it came to be called, was being promoted for two full years - in 1904 and 1905, prior to the present needs of the church in Nashville. The Review and Herald Publishing Association was anxiously awaiting its share and to support this objective ran columns listing the donations in each of its issues. Yet, it "was in the providence of God that our brethren obtained possession of this house of worship in Nashville," according to Mrs. E.G. White, and the publishing house was left to find other means.
Such were the events which converged to plant and nourish the new congregation in Nashville. How interwoven was our early church to the affairs of the church at large! In faith they prayed for a suitable place of worship. And through faith God surely answered their prayers far beyond any expectation. No outlay of congregational cash was required to secure the new building.
Let us fill this blessed house!
Equipped with a new house of worship the word went out - let us fill this blessed house! Can you imagine the excitement of the early congregation as they stepped into their new "Fatherland Memorial SDA Church"? Here was a congregation that numbered under 30 who stepped into a building which contained room for 400!
What do you think they were feeling at this time? Who would accept the challenge of filling it? God had taken them so far! Now how would they continue the work of the Lord in Nashville?
Finding the right place for city tent meetings.
As is always the case, the Lord was already orchestrating the development of His work. Looking backward in time it is remarkable to see Him in action. S.N Haskell and his wife had come to Nashville from New York City to conduct a Bible worker's school and they intended to join Elder Butler in a city wide tent effort. For two years they had prayed not only for the funds to purchase a tent but for a place to put it.
They're efforts were blocked time and time again. They couldn't seem to "land" a place for the tent. The leaders of the 1903 General Conference Session at Oakland, California had raised both the money to purchase the tent and the freight costs required to get it to Nashville. The Haskells had in their possession a tent sixty by one hundred feet.
Each time the land was sought to house the tent the deal fell through. Neighbors complained that they didn't want the tent near them, landlords refused to lease land for a tent and so forth. Then one day the "tent without a home" story was relayed to a prominent women who had been treated by the Lanes. She owned a rather large business concern in Nashville and after hearing of the matter, quickly offered a lot she owned, adding "and no one's objections will make any difference." The lot was precisely one block from the recently purchased Fatherland church!
And so the tent went up. And the people came. Attendance averaged 125 souls each night and many nights found up to 200 at that old evangelistic tent meeting. What wondrous and rich blessings pour forth from our dear Lord! In His divine providence he saw that although the tent was procured two years earlier the timing for the work in Nashville was not right until it could go on right beside the new church!
A better spot could not be found in all of downtown Nashville! The new Fatherland Street Church, just one block down the road, provided instant credibility to the campaign and the newspapers broadcast the message that the Seventh-day Adventist denomination had arrived in Nashville. From 1905 to 1954 that small band of thirteen believers grew into a large congregation, worshipping Lord in the Fatherland Street Memorial Seventh-day Adventist church.
It was around the fall of 1943, according to a document produced by C. P. Harris who served as Certified Public Accountant for the church, that another city wide evangelistic effort was conducted by Jay M. Hoffman. This resulted in the addition of over 140 new members and necessitated the building of a balcony at the church. By the way, the budget to build the balcony was $5,300.
However, according to notes provided by Shirley Eldrigde, the balcony could only hold 60 people. And once again, the congregation found they were in need of a larger structure. The members approached the President of the Kentucky-Tennessee Conference and began to examine options. But it wasn't until August of 1946 when Elder W. E. Strickland was called away from being Pastor of the Fatherland Street Church to President of the General Conference of Seventh-day Adventists that the effort to enlarge or relocate the church really began to take form.
Continuing growth led to need for a larger house of worship.
Elder E. L. Pingenot was called from the church at Battle Creek, Michigan to take charge of the flourishing church. He had a reputation for building churches and true to his calling, he arrived in Nashville and began to forge a new vision - a new house of worship.
By the spring of 1952 over $50,000 had been raised for a new building. Imagine this! From a poor flock who couldn't raise $5000 to a growing membership who gladly accepted the call to pledge funds for a new church home.
A Building Committee was selected to manage the program as follows: Elder E. L. Pingenot, Chairman; James Atwood, Building Supervisor; R. M. Eldridge; A. J. Frank; R. E. Finney; James Fry; J. W. Freeze; C. P. Harris, G. B. Kathka; Frank Kurzynake; N. C. Nelsen. A John J. Parmalee was selected as Architect and on May 18, 1952 the first shovel full of dirt was turned on a lot purchased at the corner of Blair Boulevard and Natchez Trace, the site of our current church facility.
The spirit with which Elder Pingenot touched the congregation was so acutely felt that the building never had to stop due to lack of funds. Each week the expenses were paid and in March, 1953, Elder W. B. Ochs from the General Conference laid the corner stone. Of this time, James Atwood writes:
"As I think back of the untiring effort and the wonderful counsel and the splendid leadership that Elder Pingenot gave to this congregation it was proof to me that God had raised Himself up a faithful Pastor who would come to work with this group and help to build this beautiful church in the Southland that God had planned for so long ago..."
"I remember hearing Elder Pingenot say that for a long time she (Sister Alice Swift) and a few old widow women had given more than any of the richest men in the church. I remember hearing him say that she gave...sizable amounts." During "the time we worked on the church "she was suffering from a cancer. It had eaten her jaw bone away until she had lost most of the normal shape of her face and it was a great hindrance to her when she tried to eat or talk. She could have given her money to doctors seeking medical help...but no, she chose to bring her gifts to Jesus and lay them at his feet. When I would look at or even think of her, I would determine in my heart that as long as I have charge of the building of this church, there would never be one cent's worth of labor or material wasted if I can prevent it."
Finally, on May 1, 1954, a dedication service for the First Nashville SDA Church was held. Officiating on behalf of the General Conference was Elder W. P. Bradley. Others taking part in the program were Elders V.G. Anderson, W. E. Strickland, E. L. Pingenot and J. O. Marsh. The honorable Frank G. Clement, governor of Tennessee, attended the service and much publication was given of the event.
Music furnished during the dedication service was performed by Frances Harris Osborne as soloist, a quartet from Southern Missionary College comprised of Duane Stier, Art Butterfield, Johnny Harris and Jim McClintock, and a trio, R. M. Eldridge, Don F. Haynes and S. C. Eldridge. Miss Lavanne Hazelton was organist and Newell Niswonger, Chorister, was supported by the Church Chior.
Yes, our First Nashville SDA Church had finally arrived. All according to God's wondrous plan for evangelizing the South. Can you see how His hand made this all possible? Yet so much lies far removed from the big headlines. And somewhere tucked behind the scenes there were countless sacrifices which often are forgotten. In this context, Mr. Atwood's notes paint an important literary portrait of a godly black man named Reverend Morgan Fryerson.
The Lord blesses the builders of His house.
The Reverend was a Baptist preacher whom Mr. Atwood sought to hire as soon as he learned that he was chosen to supervise the building of the church. It appears that the Reverend accepted the engagement more as a call to serve the Lord he loved and cherished than as an employee.
His wages were set at $2.00 per hour although he could easily have earned more. Yet by the end of the week when his wages were paid, he refused to take his earned wage much preferring to donate .90 per hour to the Lord's work. During the two years it took to build the church his ninety cent donations totaled up to the hefty sum of $3,600.
Such graciousness can only spring from a heart touched by Jesus. Herein lies a Baptist with a lot of Seventh-day Adventists at heart. You and me and everyone who comes through our doors. Yet there is so much more to this incredible story! For Mr. Atwood, the Reverend was a consummate joy to work with. They spent many long and unpaid hours adding finishing touches that were far beyond the requirements of the building plan. Indeed, the city building engineers who reviewed the plan expressed concern over the fact that it was so very complicated.
A large stone bluff had to be blown up with many sticks of dynamite in order that the foundation be properly laid. The angle of the church in relation to how it sits on the lot and with reference to the incline of the land made surveying and building it difficult. There were two springs that survived the blasts of dynamite and they had to be rerouted otherwise we would have ended up with a natural swimming pool.
Mr. Atwood donated all of his time towards the building of this church. It was his boyhood dream to build a church. He knew deep in his heart that this was his specific calling in life. Finally, the dedication for the church was planned and it seemed appropriate that the Reverend should grace the church with his presence on that special day. But he would not. He was black and at that time he reasoned that his presence would have disrupted the service.
At the dedication a professor from Vanderbilt University, who frequented the site with students studying construction, hailed the building and estimated its cost at $300,000. Little did he know of the resourcefulness of Mr. Atwood and the Reverend who had succeeded in erecting the building at a cost of $80,000!
These stories melt my soul. They help me to understand that I am a mere vessel for my blessed Lord and all that I have is His. I walk the halls of this wonderful sanctuary by His grace alone. The collective efforts of those who's names will never be heard of again until that wondrous day of Jesus comprise soulful testimony that we each have the glorious privilege to help each other until we reach the fullness of Jesus Christ our Lord.
Today the First Nashville SDA church stands as a testimony of many untiring souls since passed who were committed to the cause of Jesus in the Southland. We are part of a larger, global effort to preach the good news to every kindred, tongue, nation and people.
We are compelled by the clear warnings of the three angels messages of Revelation 14 as we seek to reveal that mankind is living in the last days when all must decide whom they will serve. Enduring countless hardships, but no more than others who have gone before us, we strive to unite together through the unifying agency of the Holy Spirit to fulfill our last task on Earth and finally, to be prepared, each one, for the soon coming of Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
The sun shine warm upon your face
"And I was glad when they said unto me, Let us go into the house of the Lord." With such a gracious heritage to share, the Nashville First Seventh-day Adventist Church has become a haven for people seeking to worship the Lord in Spirit and in Truth.
Jesus said, "I am the Way, the Truth and the Life. No man cometh unto the Father but by me." Our first commission is to preach Jesus Christ and Him crucified. As the name of Jesus is lifted in praise the hearts of our congregation is stirred in holy adoration. We love to praise the Lord.
As we seek the face of our divine Master we are impressed with ways to share His love to the surrounding community. And so social events are organized like the 50s party where our members, and anyone who wants to join with us, can come together in a spirit of fellowship and fun.
Each year we organize the International Food Festival where we can experience the epicurean delights of the diverse cultures represented in our congregation. And on Valentine's Day and Mother's Day we honor our marriages and keep them strong and meaningful through special programs focusing on Jesus Christ.
Our Sabbath hours are rich and filled with meaning. We enter the sanctuary to seek our God face to face and many times the Spirit of God moves through our congregation giving peace and comfort along the way.
We love to come together as a church family from Sabbath to Sabbath. We try as best we can to care for each other. We nurture and support a wonderfully rich spiritual experience. But most of all, we love to praise Jesus.
Jesus. Our consummate joy lies in His sweet presence. His presence is so very real in this sanctuary. We know He is intimately involved with each one of us. And we feel so compelled to share His wondrous blessings with others.
Dear friend, may the sun shine warm upon your face. May you find in our church family a people who earnestly seek to dispense the love of the One who gave His wondrous Life so that we might all live life more abundantly. And eternally with Him.
Our worship service is invigorating because we magnify the holy name of Jesus. Each one of us is challenged to experience the glorious gifts of the Spirit in everyday life; not through drawing attention and confusion but in the spirit of meekness and humility.
To all who come here each Sabbath, and to all who ever will enter these doors which were so meticulously laid down, 'May the Good Lord bless and keep you and may He cause the sun to shine warm upon your face and give you peace.' Amen.